Are Mustangs Reliable? (Best And Worst Mustang Years)

Updated on

You’re considering buying a Ford Mustang, but you’re unsure if it’s a reliable car. With so many choices out there when it comes to cars, it can be hard to know which one is the right choice for you. Are Mustangs Reliable? We’ve got the answer. 

The overall Ford Mustang reliability is 63.85, making it the most suitable and reliable vehicle. It has received a rating of 3.5 out of 5 from RepairPal, placing it 20th out of 24 midsize cars in its class. Also, a reliability rating of 85 out of 100 is given to this car by J.D. Power. In addition, the 2021 Ford Mustang was ranked first in the sports car market by US News & World Report out of eight models, and with a score of 4 out of 5, the new 2020 Ford Mustang has shown excellent reliability.

mustang years to avoid

In this article, we’ll take a look at the best and most practical Mustangs, as well as the various things to keep in mind when buying one. Continue reading to learn more about the reliability and durability of the Ford Mustang and determine whether it is the right vehicle for you. 

Why Are Mustangs Reliable?

Ford Mustang automobiles are renowned for their high performance and sports car appearance. You know that the Ford Mustang has a large following because it has been produced continuously since 1965. However, what makes it so dependable that people are so obsessed with this pony car? Let’s have a look at a few factors that make it so reliable:

A Safe vehicle

In most cases, safety tests of sports cars are not very good. The manufacturers are faced with huge challenges in terms of developing a secure ride because of the compact and convenient design. The Mustang does not appear to have that problem. It has received an overall five-star rating from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Blind spot guards, auto high-beam headlamps, and auto emergency braking are among the standard safety features.

Engine

The Mustang has interesting driving moves that make sports cars so enjoyable, offering a variety of powerful engines. It also gets good gas mileage and rides well. The 428CI Cobra Jet from the 1960s and the Shelby Supercharged 5.8L from 2013 and 2014 are two examples of some of the most potent, reliable, and dependable engines ever made.

Features and Innovation

Mustang has always been at the front line of innovation headways. Whether you choose an older or newer model, it will have a lot of technology that is a step above the rest. Ford claims to have revitalized the interior structure, which is now more technologically advanced and provides more luxury than ever.

Performance

If you want to go faster, the Ford Mustang is a favorite. With a speed of 151 mph, the 2004 model Ford Mustang Mach I will never disappoint you. There is also the 1995 Mustang SVT Cobra, which has a top speed of 160 mph. However, the 2019 Ford Mustang Bullitt, which is close to 170 mph, has to be the best of the bunch.

Affordability

It is quite reasonable and affordable for buyers to purchase a new and a used Mustang. One of the most reliable used pony cars is the model from 2011, which has a reputation for being an extremely reliable Mustang. With the high ubiquity of this car, many individuals need to possess a model. Therefore, no matter how many Mustangs are manufactured annually, they almost always end up being sold.

What Are The Best Mustang Years?

One of the most well-known automobiles ever produced is the Ford Mustang, whose origins can be traced back to the early 1960s. A wide variety of engine options and a wide range of performance packages are available for modern versions. Some of the best years of Ford Mustangs are:

2011 Ford Mustang

Over the years, the 2011 Mustang has built quite a name for itself. Nearly everyone is impressed with its featured engine, look, and performance. It is also widely regarded as the most reliable Mustang available. United States News gave the 2011 Mustang an overall rating of 8.5 out of 10. Additionally, it has been referred to as “the best pony car on the market.” 

It also has other wonderful characteristics, including keyless entry and standard features like excellent handling, high fuel economy, high safety scores, and adaptive cruise control.

2014

The fifth generation of the Mustang ended with the 2014 model, but the super powerful engines carried on. This model gets a lot of mileage for its engine’s performance. This super-powered car has various trim levels, including the humming 305 horsepower V6 engine, the 420 horsepower V8 engine, and the 662 horsepower V8 engine. 

On J.D. Power, it ranks at 82/100, and overall in terms of quality, efficiency, and reliability, it is positioned at 80th out of 100. However, its driving adventures score 83 out of 100 for reliability. Additionally, it ranks 2nd on J.D. Power’s 2014 list of the “Best Midsize Sporty Car”. 

The reliability of the 2014 Mustang is given a 4.5 out of 5 rating by Consumer Reports. U.S. News rates it 8.3 overall, 7.0 for the interior and 8.8 for safety. The 2014 Mustang also receives a 4/5 safety rating from the NHTSA.

2019

The 2019 Mustang is unquestionably a reliable model, as evidenced by the data provided by J.D. Power. It receives a score of 79 out of 100 overall. Modern automobiles are not always as reliable as we would like them to be. This is because modern automobiles’ electric-conditioned technological systems are more susceptible to failure than their relative predecessors.

The 2019 Mustang’s excellent reliability ratings are a remarkable feat. It is the sixth generation of the Mustang. So we can anticipate improvements and increased reliability. Modern safety features like passerby detection, blind spot observance, and lane-keeping assist are also included.

This model receives an 8.9 out of 10 efficiency rating, and U.S. News critics rate it 9.3/10. Additionally, it receives an 8.3 overall rating and a safety rating of 9.1. It is interesting that the 2019 Mustang does not come with a V6 engine in any of its trims. Instead, it has a V8 engine that is more powerful. 

2021

The engines of the 2021 Mustang, like those of all Mustangs, are excellent. It has engines that are powerful but quiet. It additionally accompanies standard security highlights like programmed auto crisis brakes, crash admonitions, and other classic driver assistance advancements. 

The 2021 Mustang received an overall rating of 8.8 out of 10. With a rating of 4.5 stars out of 5, or 9 out of 10, its customer reviews are more favorable. The driving experience, convenience, interior structure, and other factors all play a role in consumer ratings. According to U.S. News, this beauty model receives an exceptional rating of 9.3 out of 10. Additionally, receiving a 9.0/10 for performance and a 7.0/10 for the interior.

Good Mustang Models From Other Years

The Mustang also had a good year in 2017. Consumer Reports gives the vehicle a reliability rating of 3 out of 5 stars. It has only been recalled three times and has few complaints on Car Complaints. 

The 2018 Mustang was also very good, producing a lot of power and exuding road presence. The exterior framework was slightly reworked for this model year; the powertrain improved efficiency and performance; the V6 engine was swapped out for a V8 engine that added power and torque, and a new 10-speed auto transmission was introduced.

The 2020 Mustang gets an upgraded EcoBoost premium Mustang four-cylinder turbocharged engine with enough power to outperform the V-8 Mustangs of the past. Also, this Ford Mustang EcoBoost model got a set of 17-inch alloy wheels that look better. It received a fine rating of 85/100 from J.D Power.

The most recent Mustang models feature the most up-to-date technology, including powertrains and safety features. For 2022, Ford offered customers a greater variety of add-ons and appearance advancements to give each vehicle a more individual feel.

Check Out 2022 Ford Mustang GT Premium Coupe: Start Up, Exhaust, Walkaround, POV, Test Drive and Review:

YouTube video

What Mustang Cars Are Worst?

The Mustang has been in the spotlight for a long time, but along with the best years of this vehicle, there are some model years that are more challenging than others and are most likely to experience issues in the future.

2015 Ford Mustang

The Ford model year 2015 marked the beginning of a new era. However, the powertrain experienced new heart-pounding issues due to the redesign and alleged improvements. 

Numerous owners voiced concerns regarding brake issues. There were a lot of complaints about the auto-up and auto-down windows, the worst performance of air conditioners, and the doors opening while driving. 

Spare parts and repair costs are also not cheap or easy to find. It is also known that the driveshaft vibrates on some 2015 models in addition to the constant jerking. It received a reliability score of 1/5 from Consumer Reports. Additionally, it was included on the organization’s “Used Cars to AvoidBuying” list. 

If you want to buy a used 2015 Mustang, look carefully at the car’s body for rust. Make sure to pay special observation to the car’s underbody. Perform a test drive, examine the engine’s health, and determine whether the brakes have ever been replaced.

2016

The drivetrain of the 2016 model also has issues, including distraction in driving due to the frequent frightening vibration. According to Car Complaints, the occurrence has a severity rating of 7.6 and an average mileage of approximately 500 miles.

It is possible for the clutch in a manual transmission to fail without warning. The inability to shift gears as a result of this is certain to result in accidents. There was a rise in complaints about various engine and powertrain issues with the 2016 Mustang. 

Drivers also reported that their vehicles would unexpectedly shut off while driving and wouldn’t turn on again. The most common cause of owners losing power while driving was a broken throttle body. 

Make sure you check the mileage on the car you want to buy if you have to buy a 2016 Mustang. It could be more than the typical distance traveled to encounter any issues. If this happens, it could indicate that the car won’t likely encounter any of these issues.

2018

This is the third model year to be included in the Consumer report’s “Used Cars to Avoid Buying” list. Many Mustang fans are aware that the 2018 model year is one of the most unreliable models available. 

On Car Complaints, the car’s engine issues have a severity scoring of 10.0. According to NHTSA complaints, this issue has resulted in an accident with injuries. Engine trouble starts at around 8000 miles.

The motor might lose power or influence the vehicle to jolt while changing gears. Even at average speeds, it might make disturbingly loud noises. Thus, we do not recommend the model from 2018.

Common Problems with Mustang Cars

Even though the Ford Mustang is a solid, reliable muscle car, it still has some issues. The most frequently reported issues for various model years are as follows:

Vibration While Driving

Vibration While Driving is a common issue that some owners of the 2016 Ford Mustang encounter. Car Complaints.com reports that most Mustangs started to shake around 60 mph. The issue was brought on by a disproportioned driveshaft for some owners. The rear-end assembly was a problem for others. Another owner discovered tire issues.

Albeit no reviews have been given to resolve this issue, it is functional in nearby showrooms.

Interior Accessories Issues

Interior equipment issues are among the most announced 2017 Portage Colt issues. A few drivers experienced difficulties with the vehicle’s radio. One owner claims that the display will only show the temperature and time when the sync is connected to a phone or when the radio is playing. 

The steering wheel, the steering assistance light, and the rearview camera all present additional issues.

Hood Corrosion

Corrosion on the hood has been a problem with older Ford Mustang models for a long time. This issue is likewise connected with the paint rankling displayed by certain 2007 and 2010 Portage Horse units.

Ford used aluminum hoods but did not properly insulate them as done in the previous model year, resulting in this issue. Despite the fact that the issue is known to affect all Ford Mustang models, the manufacturer has not issued a recall to address it.

Body Paint Issues

Body paint issues are one of the most frequently reported issues by many owners of 2007 Ford Mustangs. They’ve seen how to paint cracks around their bumpers. Others noted extreme stripping and breaking off the front edge of the hood.

Most owners were informed that the problem could not be solved because the oxidation would continue to occur despite the fact that some owners took action and brought their vehicles to the repair facility.

Issues With Camshaft Sensor Placement

Among the most frequently reported issues with the 2004 Ford Mustang are loud chirping or squeaking sounds. The car made chirping noises when it was cold, according to a RepairPal complaint. When the vehicle got warm, the noise reportedly stopped or faded away. According to another owner, the vehicle chirps when driven in the winter.

A damaged upper bushing can cause the synchronizer shaft to hear loud chirping or squeaking. As the engine warms up, the erratic noise may disappear. According to reports, these issues also affected model years 1999, 2000, and 2002 to 2010. 

Other Factors When Deciding To Buy A Used Mustang

Most people sell their used cars because they have some problems. If you intend to purchase a used Ford Mustang, find out why the owner is selling it. Also, find out about any previous repairs. Find out what prices are currently available before you go shopping for a Mustang. Use these prices as a bargaining tool by printing them out. If you know how to bargain effectively, you can get a fair price. 

You could test drive it and have a reputable licensed mechanic thoroughly inspect the vehicle. Wait until the mechanic gives you the “go ahead” signal before purchasing the vehicle.

Best Looking Mustang (Year)

Due to its powerful V8 engine, as well as its stunning appearance and variety of body styles, the Ford Mustang is now a household name. Let us drop the curtains and take a close look at the top ten best-looking Ford Mustangs ever made: 

  1. 1993-2004 Ford Mustang SVT Cobra R
  2. 1984 Ford Mustang SVO
  3. 1978 Ford Mustang II King Cobra
  4. 1968 Ford Mustang Bullitt
  5. 2022 Ford Mustang California Special
  6. 1969-1970 Ford Mustang Boss 302/351/429
  7. 1965-1970 Ford Shelby Mustang GT 500
  8. 1964 Original 1964 ¼ Ford Mustang 289
  9. 1969 Ford Mustang Mach 1
  10. 1965 Ford Shelby Mustang GT350

Most Popular Mustang (Year)

Let’s take a look at the top ten most famous Ford Mustangs ever produced.

  1. 1965 Shelby GT350
  2. 1969 Boss 429
  3. 1966 Ford Mustang Fastback
  4. 1964 Ford Mustang
  5. 1993 SVT Cobra
  6. 2015 Shelby GT350R
  7. 2000 Cobra R Mustang
  8. 2008 Ford Mustang Bullitt
  9. 2012 Ford Mustang Boss 302 Laguna Seca edition
  10. 2019 Ford Mustang Bullitt

Which Mustang To Buy Used?

Purchasing a used Mustang is an excellent option if you have been longing to own one at a lower cost. We’ve compiled a list of three of the best-used Mustang models to help you choose from. According to Consumer Reports, these particular models have the highest ratings for reliability in addition to ratings of proprietor satisfaction.

2011 Mustang

Two brand-new engines adorned this model: a 3.7-liter 305-horsepower V6 and a 412-horsepower 5-liter V8. Either an automatic or a six-speed manual transmission could be used to couple these engines. The 2011 Shelby GT500 has a massive 550 horsepower thanks to its 5.8-liter V8 engine, providing even more power. Overall, the 2011 Mustang is very agile, well-balanced, and fun to drive. 

2014 Mustang

The well-equipped and reasonably priced 2014 Mustang is another appealing option. The 2014 Mustang is available with a variety of performance options, including a 420-horsepower, 5-liter V8 engine, and a 305-horsepower, 7-liter V6 engine. You can also upgrade to the extremely potent 5.8-liter V8 engine, which produces 662 horsepower. Additionally, the fuel efficiency of this model is higher than average. 

2019 Mustang

The reliability rating of the 2019 Mustang is slightly higher than that of its predecessors. The Mustang 2019 model has a 2.3-liter EcoBoost 4-cylinder engine and produces 310 horsepower. It is a good choice if you want to save money on gas. However, as you probably already know, the Mustang is best known for its powerful V8 engines. The 460-hp, 5-liter V8 and the 526-hp, 5.2-liter V8 are two additional options.

FAQs

Do Mustangs retain their value?

The renowned Ford Mustang maintains its value admirably and ranks among the top 25 most popular models in years 5 and 7. A Ford Mustang will lose 24% of its value after a period of 5 years, giving it a $37,281 resale value after five years. Ford keeps on putting resources into the Mustang stage with its elite presentation models, and that venture has been taken care of in both the new and utilized commercial centers. 

Is a Mustang GT reliable?

Yes, the Ford Mustang GT’s reliability rating is 4 out of 5 from JD Power. The Mustang GT has also been recognized as one of the most reliable pony cars on the market by consumer reviews. Given that not all Mustangs receive high ratings, this is impressive.

The 4-piston calipers on the Mustang GT make it faster than the EcoBoost Mustang. Brembo brakes are included in the GT Performance Package’s efficient radiator, including the rear wing and bar. It has easy-to-use controls and a top speed of 180 mph

Are EcoBoost Mustangs reliable?

Even though there are not many complaints from customers, it’s still believed that the Mustang EcoBoost is one of the Ford Mustangs’ reliable models. It has a torque of 320 pound-feet and 310 hp. Due to the exceptionally superior execution of its turbocharged motor, this engine is ideal for fast drivers. 

The EcoBoost has only two-piston motors and is also less heavy frontally than the Mustang GT. It has the same expected power from the engine despite being more agile and lighter to drive. Additionally, the EcoBoost Mustang equipped with the High-Performance Package can reach 155 mph. 

What Is the Best Engine for a Mustang?

The 2013 GT500, which has 662 hp and produces a torque of 631 pound-feet, is the most powerful Mustang that Ford has ever produced. It was also the most powerful engine ever built for a North American production car. 

To achieve those numbers, the aluminum-block 5.8-liter V8 makes use of a whopping 2.3-liter supercharger that adds a boost of 14psi. However, it can still achieve 24 mpg on the highway. The vehicle’s launch control helps it reach 60 mph in 3.5 seconds, and modern aerodynamics allow it to reach a fine speed of 189 miles per hour. 

Final Thoughts

To summarize, Mustangs receive a reliability rating of 4/5 stars from JDPower. For five years, consumers all over the world made the Ford Mustang the best sports car in the world. This data demonstrates that the Ford Mustang is one of the sports cars with the highest trust and reliability worldwide.

A Ford Mustang might be a good option if you want a sports car. Also, don’t buy a used Mustang because some of the earlier trims have had issues. Or if you want to go for a used one, then do follow all the precautionary measures first.

Photo of author
Written By
Matt's life has been driven by his great love for cars, from the revving sounds of his childhood to the digital tracks of Gran Turismo. He is a big fan of cars and loves to learn about their inner workings and share his knowledge with other car fans. Even though he doesn't have ASE certifications, he works on cars all the time, so he's always up to date on the latest innovations and trends. Matt doesn't just want to write; he also wants to connect with other people who love cars as much as he does.